Part 2: Fiduciary Duties to Shareholders, Partners, and Members
25 What duties are owed in an LLC?
Duties in an LLC are similar to those in a general partnership. The LLC operating agreement may provide for either a member-managed LLC or a manager-managed (centralized) LLC. If the former, all members have actual and apparent authority to bind the LLC to contracts on its behalf, as in a partnership, and all members’ votes have equal weight unless otherwise agreed. Member-managers have fiduciary duties, though the parameters of those duties vary from state to state. If the firm is manager managed, only managers have authority to bind the firm; the managers have the duty of care and fiduciary duty, but the nonmanager members usually do not. In this sense, they may be treated more like shareholders in a corporation or limited partners in a limited partnership: their primary role is investing, not managing. Some states’ statutes provide that voting is based on the financial interests of the members. Most statutes provide that any extraordinary firm decisions be voted on by all members (e.g., amend the agreement, admit new members, sell all the assets prior to dissolution, merge with another entity). Members can make their own rules without the structural requirements (e.g., voting rights, notice, quorum, approval of major decisions) imposed under state corporate law.
Exercises
- Create a chart that compares the (a) liability, (b) taxation, and (c) duties owed to the entities of a (i) corporation, (ii) general partnership, (iii) limited partnership, and (iv) LLC. (You will be creating a 3×4 table.)