35 Modernism in America

American Painting: The Ashcan School

The Ashcan School was a movement within American Realism known for portraying scenes of daily life in New York’s poorer neighborhoods.

Learning Objectives

  • Describe the origins and focus of the Ashcan School.

Key Points

  • American Realism arose in the late 19th and early 20th centuries with works of art that depicted contemporary views of daily life, and the Ashcan School was central to that movement.
  • The artists of the Ashcan School rebelled against American Impressionism, contrasting the Impressionists’ emphasis on light with Realist works that were darker in tone and captured harsher moments in life.
  • Ashcan School artists portrayed prostitutes, drunks, butchered pigs, overflowing tenements, and boxing matches. Their focus on poverty and the daily realities of urban life prompted critics to consider them on the fringe of Modern art.

Key Terms

  • American Realism: An early 20th century idea in art, music, and literature that reflected contemporary issues and events.
  • American Impressionism: American Impressionism was a style of painting related to European Impressionism and practiced by American artists in the United States during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. American Impressionism is a style of painting characterized by loose brushwork and vivid colors.

Overview

The Ashcan School was a movement within American Realism that came into prominence in New York City during the early 20th century and is best known for works portraying scenes of daily life in New York’s poorer neighborhoods.

American Realism

American Realism was a concept that arose in the late 19th and early 20th centuries in art, music, and literature. Whether it was a portrayal of contemporary culture, or a scenic view of downtown New York City, Realist works depicted a contemporary view of what was happening or what was “real.”

In America at the beginning of the 20th century, a new generation of painters, writers, and journalists were coming of age who were interested in creating a new style that reflected city life and an American population that was becoming increasingly more urban as the country entered the new century. American Realism attempted to portray the exhaustion and cultural exuberance of the American landscape and the life of ordinary people at home. Artists used the rapidly growing setting of the city – increasingly a city of immigrants – to influence the color, texture, and look of their creative projects.

Until the first decade of the 20th century American art was still looking to Europe – especially the French Impressionists – to provide models of “modernism”. While many would continue to paint in an Impressionistic style, after the Armory Show in 1913 American art began to experiment with a number of styles and ideas that would allow a number of distinctively “American” kinds of painting to emerge. Pulling away from fantasy and focusing on the grit and reality of daily life, American Realism presented a breakthrough—introducing Modernism, and what it means to be in the present. The Ashcan School, also known as “The Eight,” was central to the new American Modernism in the visual arts.

The Ashcan School

The Ashcan School was a group of New York City artists who sought to capture the feel of turn-of-the-century New York through realistic portraits of everyday life. The movement grew out of a group known as The Eight, many of whom had experience as newspaper illustrators, and whose only show together in 1908 created a sensation. These artists were not only depicting Fifth Avenue socialites, but also the lower class and richly textured immigrant cultures. Critics of the time did not always appreciate their choice of subjects, which included alleys, tenements, slum dwellers, and in the case of John French Sloan, taverns frequented by the working class.

Five artists of The Eight, William Glackens, Robert Henri, George Luks, Everett Shinn, and John French Sloan became associated with the Ashcan School. However, the Ashcan School was not an organized group. Instead their unity consisted of a desire to tell truths about the state of the city. The first known use of the “ashcan” terminology in describing the movement was by Art Young in 1916.

Two men seated and one wearing suits standing in a dark room
Shinn Henri Sloan: Everett Shinn, Robert Henri, and John Sloan, c. 1896 (unidentified photographer, black and white print, 18 x 13 cm)

The artists of the Ashcan School rebelled against the New York Design Academy – the equivalent of the European Academic schools – with its focus on upper-class American portraiture and a style of American Impressionism, which was the vanguard of American art at the time. In contrast to the Impressionists’ emphasis on light and retinal impression, their Realist works were generally darker in tone, capturing harsher moments of life and often portraying such subjects as prostitutes, drunks, butchered pigs, overflowing tenements, boxing matches, and wrestlers. It was their frequent, although not total, focus upon poverty and the daily realities of urban life that prompted American critics to consider them to be on the fringe of Modern art.

Two men fighting in a boxing ring surrounded by crowds
Both Members of This Club: Both Members of This Club by George Bellows, 1909 (oil on canvas, National Gallery of Art)

Modern Photography in America

Photography developed as an art form throughout the early 20th century largely due to a number of artists who worked to legitimize the medium by moving it into a gallery setting.

Learning Objectives

Describe the establishment of photography as an art form in the early 20th century.

 

Key Points

  • In the early 1900s, the Daguerreotype emerged as the most popular and affordable photographic method for the general public.
  • In 1884 George Eastman, of Rochester, New York, developed dry gel on paper, or film, to replace the photographic plate so that a photographer no longer needed to carry boxes of plates and toxic chemicals around, further popularizing the medium.
  • Alfred Stieglitz and Edward Steichen were instrumental in making photography a fine art, and Stieglitz was especially notable in introducing it into museum collections.
  • In addition to his fame as a photographer, Stieglitz is known as a writer, publisher, exhibition organizer, and collector. As an owner of multiple New York art galleries, he introduced many photographers and other artists, including new European avante-garde artists, to the U.S. art world.
  • Stieglitz was involved in a number of photographic organizations and journals in New York city throughout his career. He used these platforms to promote photography as a fine art, and contributed to its acceptance in the art world.
  • The Photo-Secession movement placed the focus on the role of the photographer as an artist and was characterized by pictorialism, in which pictures and photographic materials were manipulated to emulate the quality of paintings and etchings being produced at that time.

Key Terms

  • abstract: Free from representational qualities. Abstract art uses a visual language of form, color, and line to create a composition that exists with a degree of independence from visual references in the world.

History of Photography – a Review

The history of photography has roots in antiquity with the discovery of the principle of the camera obscura, and the observation that some substances are visibly altered by exposure to light. In the mid-1820s, Nicéphore Niépce succeeded in fixing an image, but several days of exposure in the camera were required and the earliest results were very crude. Niépce’s associate Louis Daguerre went on to develop the Daguerreotype process, the first publicly announced photographic process, which required only minutes of exposure in the camera and produced clear, finely detailed results. It was commercially introduced in 1839, a date generally accepted as the birth year of practical photography.

Throughout the late 1800s and early 1900s a number of competing processes were experimented with and distributed to the public in varying degrees. The demand for portraiture that emerged from the middle classes during the Industrial Revolution could not be met in volume and in cost by oil painting, a factor that added to the push for the development of photography. Eventually, the Daguerreotype emerged as the most popular and affordable method for the general public, however, Daguerreotypes were fragile and difficult to copy, and lacked portability as they required plates and toxic chemicals to be carried around.

In 1884 George Eastman, of Rochester, New York, developed dry gel on paper, or film, to replace the photographic plate so that a photographer no longer needed to carry boxes of plates and toxic chemicals around. In July 1888 Eastman’s Kodak camera went on the market with the slogan “You press the button, we do the rest.” Now anyone could take a photograph and leave the complex parts of the process to others, and photography became available for the mass-market in 1901 with the introduction of the Kodak Brownie.

Photography as Art

Successful attempts to make fine art photography can be traced to Victorian era practitioners such as Julia Margaret Cameron, Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, Oscar Gustave Rejlander, and others. In the U.S., F. Holland Day, Ansel Adams, Alfred Stieglitz, and Edward Steichen were instrumental in making photography a fine art, and Stieglitz was especially notable in introducing it into museum collections. Until the late 1970s several genres predominated, such as nudes, portraits, and natural landscapes. Breakthrough artists in the 1970s and 80s, such as Sally Mann, Robert Mapplethorpe, Robert Farber, and Cindy Sherman, still relied heavily on such genres, although saw them with fresh eyes. Others investigated a snapshot aesthetic approach. American organizations, such as the Aperture Foundation and the Museum of Modern Art, have done much to keep photography at the forefront of the fine arts.

Photo-Secession Movement

Photographer Alfred Steiglitz (1864–1946) led the Photo-Secession movement, a movement that promoted photography as a fine art and sought to raise standards and awareness of art photography. The Photo-Secession movement placed the focus on the role of the photographer as an artist. It was characterized by pictorialism, in which pictures and photographic materials were manipulated to emulate the quality of paintings and etchings being produced at that time. Among the methods used were soft focus; special filters and lens coatings; burning, dodging and/or cropping in the darkroom to edit the content of the image; and alternative printing processes such as sepia toning, carbon printing, platinum printing or gum bichromate processing.

Man with a thick mustache, sitting before a white curtain and holding a hat
Gertrude Käsebier, Portrait of Alfred Stieglitz: A picture of Alfred Stieglitz by Gertrude Käsebier, 1902

Centered in Gallery 291 in New York City from 1902–1916, membership to the Photo-Secession movement was by invitation-only and varied according to Stieglitz’s interests. The most prominent members included Edward Steichen, Clarence H. White, Gertrude Käsebier, Frank Eugene, F. Holland Day, and Alvin Langdon Coburn.

A man looking forward with delicate hands on chin
Alfred Stieglitz, Georgia O’Keeffe, Hands: Alfred Stieglitz, Georgia O’Keeffe, Hands, 1918

At the same time, however, photography’s use as a tool of realistic documentation mirrored the growth of American Realism in art and sculpture. Many photographers sought to capture everyday life of American people—both the wealthy and the poor—in a realistic and often gritty fashion. Lewis Hine (1874–1940) used light to illuminate the dark areas of social existence in his Pittsburgh Survey (1907), which investigated working and living conditions in Pittsburgh. He later became the photographer for the National Child Labor Committee. Paul Strand (1890–1976) created brutally direct abstractions, close-up portraits, and documented machines and cityscapes.

Precisionist Movement in Photography

Edward Weston (1886–1958) would become a leader in the Precisionist Movement, a style that functioned in direct opposition to the Photo-Secession Movement. This movement was the first true use of modernism in photography. It was characterized by sharp focus and carefully framed images. James Van Der Zee (1886–1983) was an African American photographer who became emblematic of the Harlem Renaissance movement. He was best known for his portraits of black New Yorkers and produced the most comprehensive documentation of the period.

Commercial Photography

Commercial photography also expanded during this time, as in the works of Edward Steichen (1879–1973). Steichen broke with Stieglitz toward the end of the Photo-Secession movement and created the first commercial image in 1919, entitled Pear and Apple. His work was featured in magazines such as Vanity Fair. Ansel Adams (1902–1984) also began his career as a commercial photographer and became widely known for his images of American landscapes.

Gray photo of a river winding through forests towards high snowy mountains
Ansel Adams, The Tetons and the Snake River, 1942: A typical Ansel Adams photograph featuring the American landscape in black and white

The Armory Show

The Armory Show of 1913 displayed the work of European avant-garde artists alongside their American counterparts.

Learning Objectives

Discuss the influence of the Armory Show in introducing the artistic styles of Impressionism, Fauvism, and Cubism to the American public.

Key Points

  • The Armory Show of 1913 displayed about 1,300 works by over 300 artists with the goal of bringing the best avant-garde European art to an American audience.
  • Contemporary responses to the European Impressionist, Fauvist, and Cubist works were filled with accusations of quackery, insanity, immorality, and anarchy.
  • The Armory Show introduced New Yorkers accustomed to the naturalistic art of American Realism to the styles of European avant-garde artists and served as a catalyst for American artists to create their own artistic language.
  • The Armory Show has since evolved into an annual contemporary art fair.

Key Terms

  • Fauvism: An artistic movement of the last part of the 19th century that emphasized spontaneity and the use of extremely bright colors.
  • Cubism: An early 20th century avant-garde art movement pioneered by Pablo Picasso and Georges Braque, where objects are analyzed, broken up, and reassembled in an abstracted form.
  • American Realism: An early 20th century idea in art, music, and literature that reflected contemporary issues and events.

The Armory Show was the first exhibition organized by the Association of American Painters and Sculptors. The exhibition ran in New York City’s 69th Regiment Armory from February 17 until March 15, 1913 and displayed about 1,300 paintings, sculptures, and decorative works by over 300 artists. The initial premise of the show was to exhibit the best avant-garde European art alongside the best works of American artists to audiences in New York City, Chicago, and Boston.

Poster with a red and blue flag with a tree and words announcing guests and details of International Exhibition of Modern Art
Armory Show Poster, 1913: A poster displaying the name of the show, the time and place of the show, and the featured artists

Impressionism, Fauvism, and Cubism were among the European avant-garde schools represented. News reports and reviews of the show were filled with accusations of quackery, insanity, immorality and anarchy, often including parodies, caricatures, and mock exhibitions. Criticism aside, civil authorities did not interfere with the show. Among the scandalously radical works of art were Marcel Duchamp’s Cubist/Futurist style Nude Descending a Staircase (1912), in which he expressed motion with successive superimposed images.

Blurred shapes representing a nude person going down stairs
Nude Descending a Staircase, No. 2 by Marcel Duchamp: Marcel Duchamp, Nude Descending a Staircase, No. 2, 1912, oil on canvas, 58 x 35 in. Philadelphia Museum of Art

Art critic Julian Street wrote that the work resembled “an explosion in a shingle factory” while cartoonists satirized the piece. Gutzon Borglum (sculptor, famously, of the presidential portraits on Mount Rushmore), one of the early organizers of the show, labeled this piece “A staircase descending a nude,” while J. F. Griswold, a writer for the New York Evening Sun, entitled it “The rude descending a staircase (Rush hour in the subway).” Despite these negative reactions, the purchase of Paul Cézanne’s Hill of the Poor (View of the Domaine Saint-Joseph) by the Metropolitan Museum of Art signaled an integration of Modernism into the established New York museums. Duchamp’s brother, going by the “nom de guerre” Jacques Villon, also exhibited at the Armory Show, striking a sympathetic chord with New York collectors.The exhibition went on to the Art Institute of Chicago and then to The Copley Society of Art in Boston.

Cubic drawings of men and cats in a house telling a story
Caricature of Cubism at the Armory Show: “A Slight Attack of Third Dimentia Brought on by Excessive Study of the Much Talked of Cubist Pictures in the International Exhibition at New York,” drawn by John French Sloan in April 1913. Published before 1923

The Armory Show introduced New Yorkers accustomed to the naturalistic art of American Realism to the styles of the European avant-gardes. The show also served as a catalyst for American artists, who subsequently began to experiment more and became more independent in creating their own artistic language. There have been many exhibitions throughout the 20th century that celebrated the show’s legacy. The “New” New York Armory Show was held in piers on the Hudson River in 1994  and has since evolved into an annual contemporary art fair.

Precisionism

This movement was never a formally organized movement; the artists generally grouped under the title were painting at the same time, around 1920, and their style was a kind of fusion of the industrial or geometric shapes of Futurism and the planar qualities of Cubism. Generally abstract in the stylization of subjects and often in unexpected cropping or point of view, Precisionism above all celebrated American industry in a moment when it was booming. From 1910 through the 20’s America’s economy expanded; the visual correlatives of Modernism in America – urban skyscrapers, the Ford River Rouge motor works in Dearborn Michigan, or the steel mills of Pittsburgh, were depicted by the Precisionist artists as modern icons as significant as the Pyramids in Egypt or the Eiffel Tower.

Charles Demuth, Charles Sheeler, and Elsie Driggs are among the better known artists painting in the Precisionist style. It was Alfred H. Barr, the director of the Museum of Modern Art in New York, that officially used the name “Precisionists” to describe the group in 1927.2 The style continued in some popularity until the end of WWII when the atomic bomb made technology seem less attractive just as it had to the Italian Futurists in the wake of WWI.

Large yellow five with a No. 5 on a red and gray background
Charles Demuth, The Figure 5 in Gold, 1928. Oil, graphite, ink, and gold leaf on paperboard, 35 ½ x 30”, MET, PD Art

Demuth lived in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, his whole life. His work celebrated the symbols of industry and American life in that city. He had studied in Paris and been befriended by Marsden Hartley, Alfred Stieglitz, and the poet William Carlos Williams whose poem “The Great Figure” is the subject of Demuth’s painting.

Tall dark pipes in a smoky haze
Elsie Driggs, Pittsburgh, 1927. Oil on canvas, 34 1/4 × 40 1/4 in., Whitney Museum of Art, Fair Use

The only woman to be associated with the Precisionist movement, Driggs was from a wealthy New York family and studied with members of the Ashcan School. Her most famous work, Pittsburgh, depicted the smokestacks of the Jones & Laughlin steel mills in that city. Like her male counterparts she was interested in the images of industry as emblems of the dynamism and progress of America in the 1920s and painted them in the most modern style that referenced Cubism, Futurism, and the geometric planar style of Cézanne. With the stock market crash of 1929 and the Great Depression that followed, Driggs abandoned the style, married and turned to other mediums.

Harlem Renaissance

The Harlem renaissance was an arts and literary movement in the 1920s that brought African- American culture to mainstream America.

Learning Objective:

  • Analyze the Harlem Renaissance.

Key Points:

  • Racial consciousness was the prevailing theme of the Harlem Renaissance, an African- American cultural movement in the 1920s named for the historically black Harlem neighborhood of New York City.
  • The Renaissance was built upon the “New Negro Movement”, which was founded in 1917 by Hubert Harrison and Matthew Kotleski as a reaction to race and class issues, including calls for political equality and the end of segregation.
  • In several essays included in the 1925 anthology, The New Negro, editor Alain Locke contrasted the “Old Negro” with the “New Negro” by stressing African-American assertiveness and self-confidence during the years following World War I and the Great Migration.
  • Seeking to counteract the rise in racism during the postwar years, black artists, writers and musicians developed unique styles that challenged pervading stereotypes of African- American culture as the Harlem Renaissance developed.

During the early portion of the 20th Century, Harlem became home to a growing “Negro” middle class. In 1910, a large block along 135th Street and Fifth Avenue was purchased by various African-American realtors and a church group. Many more African-Americans arrived during World War I. Due to the war, the migration of laborers from Europe virtually ceased, while the war effort resulted in a massive demand for unskilled industrial labor. The Great Migration brought hundreds of thousands of African-Americans from the South to cities like Chicago, Philadelphia, Cleveland, and New York. Among them were a great number of artists whose influence would come to bear, especially in Jazz music.

Artists of the Harlem Renaissance distinguished themselves in theater, literature, music, and the visual arts. Langston Hughes, Zora Neale Hurston, Aaron Douglas, Jacob Lawrence, Augusta Savage, Romare Bearden, and many others created work in an extraordinary moment of artistic expression and invention that began in about 1920.

Aaron Douglas painted murals for public buildings and in 1940 founded the Art Department at Fisk University where he taught for almost thirty years. During the Depression he painted a WPA (Works Progress Administration) mural for the 135th St. branch of the New York Public Library in Harlem. Aspects of Negro Life was a four-panel series that chronicled the social and cultural history of African Americans from slavery to modern life.

Blurry figures of men dancing and partying behind yellow lights looking towards a palace on a hill
Aaron Douglas, Aspects of Negro Life: From slavery Through Reconstruction, 1934. Oil on canvas, The New York Public Library, Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, Art and Artifacts Division. Fair Use

Jacob Lawrence is best known for his series of Migration paintings. His tempera paintings of the movement of African Americans from the South to the North are among his most significant.

Crowds of people at gates labeled Chicago, New York, and St. Louis
Panel 1 of the series. 1941 caption: “During the World War there was a great migration North by Southern Negros.” 1993 caption: “During World War I there was a great migration north by southern African Americans.” Source (WP:NFCC#4) Fair Use

Augusta Savage was a sculptor, activist, and teacher, and was the first black artist to be elected to the National Association of Women Painters and Sculptors.3 Much of her work was in clay or plaster; bronze was too expensive for her and she struggled with finances for much of her life.

Her work was realistic and expressive, unlike the more abstract work of many artists of the time.

Dark woman in a dress leaning against a statue of two dark-skinned naked people
Andrew Herman, photographer, Augusta Savage posing with her Sculpture, ca. 1938. 8.2 x 10.2”, Archives of American Art PD Art

Regionalism

In 1929 the economic boom ended with the crash of the stock market and the Great Depression began which would continue for over a decade. During the 1930s in the Plains states it was exacerbated by the Dust Bowl, a drought that created devastating dust storms eroding much of the top soil and causing many families to lose their farms. Migrant Mother: Nipomo, CA by photographer Dorothea Lange is the record of one such family.

In cities bread lines and soup kitchens were crowded and artists like Raphael Soyer documented that reality for the WPA Federal Arts Project. The WPA provided work for artists of all backgrounds and ethnicities. Erika Doss records that a 1935 survey showed that 41 % of WPA artists were female and most were working class.4

But these gritty images were not the most popular style of art at that time. A number of artists from rural states were making paintings that gave a heroic and positive image of the American Heartland. Thomas Hart Benton from Missouri, Grant Wood from Iowa, and John Steuart Curry from Kansas were the best-known of this “Regionalist” movement. None of these men were unsophisticated; all had an awareness of the modern styles abstraction and brought that sensibility to their images of stoic, strong American figures. Benton would go on to teach a young painter from Cody, Wyoming, named Jackson Pollock at the Art Students League in New York. Regionalism was in line with the democratic ideals of President Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal, although there is also a nationalistic quality to the stereotypical figures pictured by these artists. The extremity that the country found itself in required a more positive, hopeful art that found its expression in Regionalism. A discussion of Grant Wood’s iconic American Gothic can be seen at Grant Wood, American Gothic Authored by: Dr. Beth Harris and Dr. Steven Zucker.

Provided by: Khan Academy. License: CC BY-NC-SA: Attribution-NonCommercialShareAlike

A tall farmer with a pitchfork standing with his wife in front of a farmhouse
Grant Wood, American Gothic, 1930, oil on beaver board, 30-3/4 × 25-3/4”, The Art Institute of Chicago. PD Art
Room with paintings of people on the walls and a chandelier over a wooden table
Thomas Hart Benton, A Social History of the State of Missouri, Jefferson City, Missouri, Thomas Hart Benton room, 1935. Onasill Bill Badzo via Flickr. CC BY SA
A crowd watching before a barn as a man baptizes a woman in a tub
John Steuart Curry, Baptism in Kansas, 1928. Whitney Museum. PD-Art

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Introduction To Art by Muffet Jones is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book